Browse papers
A

Section A: Long Answer Questions

Attempt all questions.

5 questions
1long12 marks

A propped cantilever ABAB of span L=6mL = 6\,\text{m} is fixed at AA and simply supported (propped) at BB. It carries a uniformly distributed load of w=20kN/mw = 20\,\text{kN/m} over the entire span and a point load of 30kN30\,\text{kN} at the mid-span. Using the force method (method of consistent deformation), with the prop reaction at BB as the redundant, determine:

(a) the reaction at the prop BB; (b) the fixing moment at AA; (c) sketch the bending-moment diagram with salient values.

Take EIEI constant.

Step 1 — Choose the redundant

The structure is statically indeterminate to the first degree. Remove the prop at BB to obtain the primary (released) cantilever fixed at AA, free at BB. The redundant is the vertical prop reaction RBR_B (upward positive).

Compatibility: net vertical deflection at BB = 0.

δB0+RBδBB=0\delta_{B0} + R_B\,\delta_{BB} = 0

where δB0\delta_{B0} = downward deflection at BB on the primary structure due to applied loads, and δBB\delta_{BB} = deflection at BB due to unit upward load at BB.

Step 2 — Deflection at free end of cantilever due to loads (δB0\delta_{B0})

Standard cantilever (free end deflection, downward positive):

  • UDL over whole span: wL48EI\dfrac{wL^4}{8EI}
  • Point load PP at mid-span (a=L/2a=L/2): tip deflection =Pa26EI(3La)= \dfrac{Pa^2}{6EI}(3L-a)

UDL term:

wL48EI=20×648EI=20×12968EI=259208EI=3240EI\frac{wL^4}{8EI}=\frac{20\times 6^4}{8EI}=\frac{20\times1296}{8EI}=\frac{25920}{8EI}=\frac{3240}{EI}

Point-load term with P=30P=30, a=3a=3, L=6L=6:

Pa2(3La)6EI=30×32×(183)6EI=30×9×156EI=40506EI=675EI\frac{Pa^2(3L-a)}{6EI}=\frac{30\times 3^2\times(18-3)}{6EI}=\frac{30\times 9\times 15}{6EI}=\frac{4050}{6EI}=\frac{675}{EI} δB0=3240+675EI=3915EI (downward)\delta_{B0}=\frac{3240+675}{EI}=\frac{3915}{EI}\ (\text{downward})

Step 3 — Flexibility δBB\delta_{BB}

Unit upward load at tip of cantilever gives upward tip deflection:

δBB=L33EI=633EI=2163EI=72EI\delta_{BB}=\frac{L^3}{3EI}=\frac{6^3}{3EI}=\frac{216}{3EI}=\frac{72}{EI}

Step 4 — Solve compatibility

Taking downward as positive for δB0\delta_{B0} and the redundant lifting BB up:

3915EIRB72EI=0    RB=391572=54.375kN\frac{3915}{EI}-R_B\frac{72}{EI}=0\;\Rightarrow\; R_B=\frac{3915}{72}=54.375\,\text{kN} RB=54.38kN (upward)\boxed{R_B = 54.38\,\text{kN (upward)}}

Step 5 — Remaining reactions and fixing moment at A

Total load =wL+P=20×6+30=120+30=150kN= wL + P = 20\times6 + 30 = 120+30 = 150\,\text{kN}.

RA=15054.375=95.625kNR_A = 150 - 54.375 = 95.625\,\text{kN}

Fixing moment at AA (take moments of all forces about AA, sagging positive on the beam; MAM_A is the support moment):

MA=RBLwLL2PL2M_A = R_B\,L - wL\cdot\frac{L}{2} - P\cdot\frac{L}{2} MA=54.375×6120×330×3=326.2536090=123.75kN\cdotpmM_A = 54.375\times 6 - 120\times 3 - 30\times 3 = 326.25 - 360 - 90 = -123.75\,\text{kN·m}

The negative sign indicates a hogging moment at the fixed end.

MA=123.75kN\cdotpm (hogging)\boxed{M_A = 123.75\,\text{kN·m (hogging)}}

Step 6 — Bending-moment diagram (salient values)

Measuring xx from BB (prop), with RB=54.375R_B=54.375 kN upward:

At mid-span (x=3x=3 m, only UDL acting between B and C):

MC=RB×3w×3×32=54.375×320×3×1.5=163.12590=+73.125kN\cdotpm (sagging)M_C = R_B\times 3 - w\times3\times\frac{3}{2} = 54.375\times3 - 20\times3\times1.5 = 163.125 - 90 = +73.125\,\text{kN·m (sagging)}

Key ordinates:

  • MB=0M_B = 0 (prop)
  • MCM_C (mid-span) =+73.13kN\cdotpm= +73.13\,\text{kN·m} (sagging)
  • MA=123.75kN\cdotpmM_A = -123.75\,\text{kN·m} (hogging)
        +73.13 (sag, mid)
          ___
         /   \
  B_____/     \________
  0              \     |
                  \____|  A
                  -123.75 (hog)

A point of contraflexure lies between CC and AA where the BMD crosses zero.

force-methodconsistent-deformationpropped-cantilever
2long12 marks

Analyse the two-span continuous beam ABCABC described below by the slope-deflection method and determine the support moments. Sketch the bending-moment diagram.

  • Span AB=6mAB = 6\,\text{m} carries a UDL of 15kN/m15\,\text{kN/m}.
  • Span BC=4mBC = 4\,\text{m} carries a central point load of 40kN40\,\text{kN}.
  • AA is fixed, CC is a simple (hinged) end support, BB is a simple interior support.
  • EIEI is constant throughout. There is no support settlement.

Step 1 — Fixed-end moments (FEM)

Span ABAB (UDL w=15w=15, L=6L=6):

MABF=wL212=15×3612=45kN\cdotpm,MBAF=+45kN\cdotpmM^F_{AB}=-\frac{wL^2}{12}=-\frac{15\times36}{12}=-45\,\text{kN·m},\quad M^F_{BA}=+45\,\text{kN·m}

Span BCBC (central point load P=40P=40, L=4L=4):

MBCF=PL8=40×48=20kN\cdotpm,MCBF=+20kN\cdotpmM^F_{BC}=-\frac{PL}{8}=-\frac{40\times4}{8}=-20\,\text{kN·m},\quad M^F_{CB}=+20\,\text{kN·m}

(Sign convention: clockwise moment on member end positive.)

Step 2 — Slope-deflection equations (no settlement, chord rotation = 0)

θA=0\theta_A=0 (fixed). Unknowns: θB, θC\theta_B,\ \theta_C.

MAB=45+2EI6(2θA+θB)=45+EI3θBM_{AB}=-45+\frac{2EI}{6}(2\theta_A+\theta_B)=-45+\frac{EI}{3}\theta_B MBA=+45+2EI6(2θB+θA)=45+2EI3θBM_{BA}=+45+\frac{2EI}{6}(2\theta_B+\theta_A)=45+\frac{2EI}{3}\theta_B MBC=20+2EI4(2θB+θC)=20+EIθB+EI2θCM_{BC}=-20+\frac{2EI}{4}(2\theta_B+\theta_C)=-20+EI\theta_B+\tfrac{EI}{2}\theta_C MCB=+20+2EI4(2θC+θB)=20+EIθC+EI2θBM_{CB}=+20+\frac{2EI}{4}(2\theta_C+\theta_B)=20+EI\theta_C+\tfrac{EI}{2}\theta_B

Step 3 — Equilibrium / boundary conditions

At C (free end, no applied moment): MCB=0M_{CB}=0

20+EIθC+EI2θB=0    EIθC=20EI2θB(i)20+EI\theta_C+\tfrac{EI}{2}\theta_B=0\;\Rightarrow\; EI\theta_C=-20-\tfrac{EI}{2}\theta_B \quad (i)

At B (joint equilibrium): MBA+MBC=0M_{BA}+M_{BC}=0

(45+2EI3θB)+(20+EIθB+EI2θC)=0\big(45+\tfrac{2EI}{3}\theta_B\big)+\big(-20+EI\theta_B+\tfrac{EI}{2}\theta_C\big)=0 25+5EI3θB+EI2θC=0(ii)25+\tfrac{5EI}{3}\theta_B+\tfrac{EI}{2}\theta_C=0 \quad (ii)

Substitute (i)(i) into (ii)(ii). Note EI2θC=12(20EI2θB)=10EI4θB\tfrac{EI}{2}\theta_C=\tfrac12\big(-20-\tfrac{EI}{2}\theta_B\big)=-10-\tfrac{EI}{4}\theta_B:

25+5EI3θB10EI4θB=025+\tfrac{5EI}{3}\theta_B-10-\tfrac{EI}{4}\theta_B=0 15+EIθB(5314)=0,5314=20312=171215+EI\theta_B\Big(\tfrac53-\tfrac14\Big)=0,\quad \tfrac53-\tfrac14=\tfrac{20-3}{12}=\tfrac{17}{12} EIθB=15×1217=18017=10.588EI\theta_B=-\frac{15\times12}{17}=-\frac{180}{17}=-10.588

From (i)(i): EIθC=2012(10.588)=20+5.294=14.706EI\theta_C=-20-\tfrac12(-10.588)=-20+5.294=-14.706

Step 4 — Substitute back for moments

MAB=45+13(10.588)=453.529=48.53kN\cdotpmM_{AB}=-45+\tfrac13(-10.588)=-45-3.529=-48.53\,\text{kN·m} MBA=45+23(10.588)=457.059=+37.94kN\cdotpmM_{BA}=45+\tfrac23(-10.588)=45-7.059=+37.94\,\text{kN·m} MBC=20+(10.588)+12(14.706)=2010.5887.353=37.94kN\cdotpmM_{BC}=-20+(-10.588)+\tfrac12(-14.706)=-20-10.588-7.353=-37.94\,\text{kN·m} MCB=20+(14.706)+12(10.588)=2014.7065.294=0kN\cdotpm  M_{CB}=20+(-14.706)+\tfrac12(-10.588)=20-14.706-5.294=0\,\text{kN·m}\;\checkmark

Check at B: MBA+MBC=37.9437.94=0  M_{BA}+M_{BC}=37.94-37.94=0\;\checkmark

Step 5 — Results (support moments)

MA=48.53kN\cdotpm (hogging),MB=37.94kN\cdotpm (hogging),MC=0\boxed{M_A=48.53\,\text{kN·m (hogging)},\quad M_B=37.94\,\text{kN·m (hogging)},\quad M_C=0}

Step 6 — Bending-moment diagram

Free (simply supported) span moments:

  • Mid-span ABAB: wL28=15×368=67.5kN\cdotpm\dfrac{wL^2}{8}=\dfrac{15\times36}{8}=67.5\,\text{kN·m} (sag)
  • Mid-span BCBC: PL4=40×44=40kN\cdotpm\dfrac{PL}{4}=\dfrac{40\times4}{4}=40\,\text{kN·m} (sag)

Net mid-span (free moment minus average end moment):

  • ABAB mid: 67.548.53+37.942=67.543.24=+24.26kN\cdotpm (sag)67.5-\tfrac{48.53+37.94}{2}=67.5-43.24=+24.26\,\text{kN·m (sag)}
  • BCBC mid: 4037.94+02=4018.97=+21.03kN\cdotpm (sag)40-\tfrac{37.94+0}{2}=40-18.97=+21.03\,\text{kN·m (sag)}
  -48.53        -37.94        0
   A______________B___________C
      \  +24.26 /    \ +21.03/
       \______/       \_____/
slope-deflectioncontinuous-beamsupport-moments
3long12 marks

A continuous beam ABCABC is fixed at AA and CC and continuous over support BB.

  • Span AB=5mAB = 5\,\text{m}, EIEI constant, carries a UDL of 24kN/m24\,\text{kN/m}.
  • Span BC=4mBC = 4\,\text{m}, EIEI constant, carries a point load of 60kN60\,\text{kN} at 1m1\,\text{m} from BB.

Using the moment-distribution method, determine the moments at all supports. Both ends AA and CC are fully fixed.

Step 1 — Fixed-end moments

Span AB (UDL w=24w=24, L=5L=5):

MABF=wL212=24×2512=50kN\cdotpm,MBAF=+50kN\cdotpmM^F_{AB}=-\frac{wL^2}{12}=-\frac{24\times25}{12}=-50\,\text{kN·m},\quad M^F_{BA}=+50\,\text{kN·m}

Span BC (point load P=60P=60 at a=1a=1, b=3b=3, L=4L=4):

MBCF=Pab2L2=60×1×916=54016=33.75kN\cdotpmM^F_{BC}=-\frac{Pab^2}{L^2}=-\frac{60\times1\times9}{16}=-\frac{540}{16}=-33.75\,\text{kN·m} MCBF=+Pa2bL2=+60×1×316=+18016=+11.25kN\cdotpmM^F_{CB}=+\frac{Pa^2b}{L^2}=+\frac{60\times1\times3}{16}=+\frac{180}{16}=+11.25\,\text{kN·m}

Step 2 — Distribution factors at B

Both far ends fixed, so use stiffness k=4EI/Lk=4EI/L (relative).

kBA=4EI5=0.8EI,kBC=4EI4=1.0EI,k=1.8EIk_{BA}=\frac{4EI}{5}=0.8EI,\qquad k_{BC}=\frac{4EI}{4}=1.0EI,\qquad \sum k=1.8EI DFBA=0.81.8=0.4444,DFBC=1.01.8=0.5556DF_{BA}=\frac{0.8}{1.8}=0.4444,\qquad DF_{BC}=\frac{1.0}{1.8}=0.5556

A and C are fixed ⇒ no distribution there (DF = 0); they only receive carry-over.

Step 3 — Moment distribution table

Unbalanced moment at B =MBAF+MBCF=50+(33.75)=+16.25=M^F_{BA}+M^F_{BC}=50+(-33.75)=+16.25. Balancing moment =16.25=-16.25.

AA (AB)BB (BA)BB (BC)CC (CB)
DF00.44440.55560
FEM-50.00+50.00-33.75+11.25
Balance B-7.222-9.028
Carry-over-3.611-4.514
Final-53.61+42.78-42.78+6.74

Balance computation: 16.25×0.4444=7.222-16.25\times0.4444=-7.222 (to BA); 16.25×0.5556=9.028-16.25\times0.5556=-9.028 (to BC). Carry-over to A: 12(7.222)=3.611\tfrac12(-7.222)=-3.611; to C: 12(9.028)=4.514\tfrac12(-9.028)=-4.514.

Since A and C are fixed, no further balancing is required (single iteration converges exactly).

Check at B: 42.78+(42.78)=0  42.78+(-42.78)=0\;\checkmark

Step 4 — Results

MA=53.61kN\cdotpm (hog), MB=42.78kN\cdotpm (hog), MC=6.74kN\cdotpm\boxed{M_A=53.61\,\text{kN·m (hog)},\ M_B=42.78\,\text{kN·m (hog)},\ M_C=6.74\,\text{kN·m}}

Final end moments (clockwise-positive convention):

  • MAB=53.61M_{AB}=-53.61, MBA=+42.78M_{BA}=+42.78, MBC=42.78M_{BC}=-42.78, MCB=+6.74M_{CB}=+6.74 kN·m.

Step 5 — Note on BMD

Free-span sagging maxima: ABAB mid =wL28=75=\tfrac{wL^2}{8}=75 kN·m; BCBC under load =PabL=60×1×34=45=\tfrac{Pab}{L}=\tfrac{60\times1\times3}{4}=45 kN·m. Superpose the negative support-moment line (MA,MB,MC)(M_A,M_B,M_C) on these to obtain the net diagram, hogging over AA and BB.

moment-distributioncontinuous-beamcarry-over
4long12 marks

A two-span continuous beam ABCABC has AB=4mAB = 4\,\text{m} and BC=4mBC = 4\,\text{m}, with AA and CC fixed and BB a continuous support. Span ABAB carries a central point load of 48kN48\,\text{kN}; span BCBC carries a UDL of 30kN/m30\,\text{kN/m}. EIEI is constant. Using the matrix stiffness (displacement) method, treating the rotation at BB as the only active degree of freedom, determine the rotation θB\theta_B (in terms of EIEI) and the member-end moments.

Step 1 — Model and active DOF

With AA and CC fixed, the only free joint displacement is the rotation θB\theta_B. All translations are restrained (no chord rotation). So this reduces to a 1×11\times1 stiffness problem.

Step 2 — Fixed-end moments (equivalent joint load)

Span AB (central P=48P=48, L=4L=4):

MABF=PL8=48×48=24kN\cdotpm,MBAF=+24kN\cdotpmM^F_{AB}=-\frac{PL}{8}=-\frac{48\times4}{8}=-24\,\text{kN·m},\quad M^F_{BA}=+24\,\text{kN·m}

Span BC (UDL w=30w=30, L=4L=4):

MBCF=wL212=30×1612=40kN\cdotpm,MCBF=+40kN\cdotpmM^F_{BC}=-\frac{wL^2}{12}=-\frac{30\times16}{12}=-40\,\text{kN·m},\quad M^F_{CB}=+40\,\text{kN·m}

Net fixed-end moment at joint B (sum of member ends meeting at B):

MBF=MBAF+MBCF=24+(40)=16kN\cdotpmM^F_B=M^F_{BA}+M^F_{BC}=24+(-40)=-16\,\text{kN·m}

Equivalent joint load (restraining moment reversed): PB=MBF=+16kN\cdotpmP_B=-M^F_B=+16\,\text{kN·m}.

Step 3 — Structure stiffness for θB\theta_B

For a prismatic beam element, the rotational stiffness at the near joint (far end fixed) is 4EI/L4EI/L.

KBB=4EILAB+4EILBC=4EI4+4EI4=EI+EI=2EIK_{BB}=\frac{4EI}{L_{AB}}+\frac{4EI}{L_{BC}}=\frac{4EI}{4}+\frac{4EI}{4}=EI+EI=2EI

Step 4 — Solve KθB=PBK\,\theta_B = P_B

2EIθB=16    θB=162EI=8EIrad2EI\,\theta_B = 16\;\Rightarrow\;\theta_B = \frac{16}{2EI}=\frac{8}{EI}\,\text{rad} θB=8EI (positive=clockwise)\boxed{\theta_B = \frac{8}{EI}\ (\text{positive} = \text{clockwise})}

Step 5 — Member-end moments

Member-end moment == FEM ++ stiffness terms ×\times displacements. With θA=θC=0\theta_A=\theta_C=0, near-end coefficient 4EI/L4EI/L and carry-over 2EI/L2EI/L:

MAB=MABF+2EI4θB=24+EI28EI=24+4=20kN\cdotpmM_{AB}=M^F_{AB}+\frac{2EI}{4}\theta_B=-24+\frac{EI}{2}\cdot\frac{8}{EI}=-24+4=-20\,\text{kN·m} MBA=MBAF+4EI4θB=+24+EI8EI=24+8=+32kN\cdotpmM_{BA}=M^F_{BA}+\frac{4EI}{4}\theta_B=+24+EI\cdot\frac{8}{EI}=24+8=+32\,\text{kN·m} MBC=MBCF+4EI4θB=40+8=32kN\cdotpmM_{BC}=M^F_{BC}+\frac{4EI}{4}\theta_B=-40+8=-32\,\text{kN·m} MCB=MCBF+2EI4θB=+40+EI28EI=40+4=+44kN\cdotpmM_{CB}=M^F_{CB}+\frac{2EI}{4}\theta_B=+40+\frac{EI}{2}\cdot\frac{8}{EI}=40+4=+44\,\text{kN·m}

Check joint B equilibrium: MBA+MBC=3232=0  M_{BA}+M_{BC}=32-32=0\;\checkmark

Step 6 — Results

MAB=20, MBA=+32, MBC=32, MCB=+44 (all kN\cdotpm);θB=8EI\boxed{M_{AB}=-20,\ M_{BA}=+32,\ M_{BC}=-32,\ M_{CB}=+44\ \text{(all kN·m)};\quad \theta_B=\tfrac{8}{EI}}

Support moments (magnitudes): MA=20M_A=20, MB=32M_B=32, MC=44M_C=44 kN·m.

matrix-stiffness-methodbeam-elementsupport-moments
5long12 marks

A propped cantilever of span L=8mL = 8\,\text{m}, fixed at AA and simply propped at BB, carries a uniformly distributed load ww (kN/m) over the entire span. The fully plastic moment of the section is Mp=180kN\cdotpmM_p = 180\,\text{kN·m}.

(a) State the assumptions of plastic analysis. (b) Using the kinematic (mechanism) method, determine the collapse value wuw_u of the UDL. (c) Locate the plastic hinge inside the span.

(a) Assumptions of plastic analysis

  1. Material is ideally elastic–perfectly plastic (no strain hardening).
  2. The plastic moment MpM_p is reached and maintained at a plastic hinge while rotation continues.
  3. Sections remain plane; plane bending only (axial/shear interaction neglected in simple theory).
  4. Connections develop full MpM_p.
  5. Deformations up to collapse are small; collapse occurs when enough hinges form a mechanism.
  6. Loads increase proportionally (proportional loading).

(b) Collapse mechanism

A propped cantilever under UDL is indeterminate to degree 1; it needs 1+1=21+1 = 2 plastic hinges to form a mechanism:

  • one hinge at the fixed end AA (max negative moment),
  • one hinge in the span at the point of maximum sagging moment, distance xx from the propped end BB.

Virtual-work (kinematic) approach

Let the span hinge be at distance xx from BB. Give it a virtual deflection δ\delta.

Rotation of segment BB–hinge: θ1=δx\theta_1=\dfrac{\delta}{x}. Rotation of segment hinge–AA: θ2=δLx\theta_2=\dfrac{\delta}{L-x}. Rotation at the span hinge: θ1+θ2\theta_1+\theta_2. Rotation at hinge AA: θ2\theta_2.

Internal work (hinges at AA and at span point):

Wint=Mpθ2+Mp(θ1+θ2)=Mp(θ1+2θ2)=Mp(δx+2δLx)W_{int}=M_p\,\theta_2 + M_p(\theta_1+\theta_2)=M_p\Big(\theta_1+2\theta_2\Big)=M_p\left(\frac{\delta}{x}+\frac{2\delta}{L-x}\right)

External work (UDL over the whole span moving through the triangular deflection profile; triangle area =12Lδ=\tfrac12 L\,\delta):

Wext=w12LδW_{ext}=w\cdot\frac{1}{2}L\,\delta

Equate:

w12Lδ=Mpδ(1x+2Lx)    w=2MpL(1x+2Lx)w\cdot\tfrac12 L\,\delta = M_p\,\delta\left(\frac{1}{x}+\frac{2}{L-x}\right)\;\Rightarrow\; w=\frac{2M_p}{L}\left(\frac{1}{x}+\frac{2}{L-x}\right)

(c) Locate hinge — minimise ww (the true collapse load is the minimum)

Let f(x)=1x+2Lxf(x)=\dfrac{1}{x}+\dfrac{2}{L-x}. Set f(x)=0f'(x)=0:

1x2+2(Lx)2=0    2x2=(Lx)2    2x=Lx-\frac{1}{x^2}+\frac{2}{(L-x)^2}=0\;\Rightarrow\;2x^2=(L-x)^2\;\Rightarrow\;\sqrt2\,x=L-x x(2+1)=L    x=L1+2=L(21)=8×0.4142=3.314m from Bx(\sqrt2+1)=L\;\Rightarrow\;x=\frac{L}{1+\sqrt2}=L(\sqrt2-1)=8\times0.4142=3.314\,\text{m from }B

Collapse load value

With x=3.314x=3.314 m, Lx=4.686L-x=4.686 m:

1x+2Lx=13.314+24.686=0.3018+0.4268=0.7286m1\frac1x+\frac{2}{L-x}=\frac{1}{3.314}+\frac{2}{4.686}=0.3018+0.4268=0.7286\,\text{m}^{-1} wu=2MpL×0.7286=2×1808×0.7286=45×0.7286=32.79kN/mw_u=\frac{2M_p}{L}\times0.7286=\frac{2\times180}{8}\times0.7286=45\times0.7286=32.79\,\text{kN/m}

Closed-form check: the standard result is wu=Mp(6+42)L2=180×11.65764=2098.264=32.79kN/mw_u=\dfrac{M_p(6+4\sqrt2)}{L^2}=\dfrac{180\times11.657}{64}=\dfrac{2098.2}{64}=32.79\,\text{kN/m}. ✓

wu=32.79kN/m,span hinge at 3.31m from the propped end B\boxed{w_u = 32.79\,\text{kN/m},\quad \text{span hinge at } 3.31\,\text{m from the propped end }B}
plastic-analysiscollapse-loadbeam-mechanism
B

Section B: Short Answer Questions

Attempt all questions.

6 questions
6short4 marks

Define static indeterminacy and kinematic indeterminacy. For a rigid-jointed plane frame with m=8m = 8 members, j=6j = 6 joints (rigid), r=4r = 4 external reaction components, and no internal hinges, compute the degree of static indeterminacy (DSI) and the degree of kinematic indeterminacy (DKI). Assume axial deformation is considered.

Definitions

  • Static indeterminacy (DSI): the number of independent force/reaction components in excess of the equations of static equilibrium; i.e. the number of redundants that must be released to render the structure statically determinate.
  • Kinematic indeterminacy (DKI): the number of independent, unknown joint displacement components (the degrees of freedom) — translations and rotations not prevented by supports.

Degree of static indeterminacy (plane rigid frame)

DSI=(3m+r)3jDSI = (3m + r) - 3j DSI=(3×8+4)3×6=(24+4)18=2818=6DSI = (3\times8 + 4) - 3\times6 = (24+4) - 18 = 28 - 18 = 6 DSI=6\boxed{DSI = 6}

Degree of kinematic indeterminacy (plane frame)

Each free joint of a plane rigid frame has 3 possible displacements (u,v,θu, v, \theta).

DKI=3j(support restraints)DKI = 3j - (\text{support restraints})

The 4 reaction components correspond to 4 restrained displacement components.

DKI=3×64=184=14DKI = 3\times6 - 4 = 18 - 4 = 14 DKI=14 (with axial deformation considered)\boxed{DKI = 14 \ (\text{with axial deformation considered})}

Note: If members were taken as axially rigid (inextensible), the number of independent joint translations would be reduced by the number of independent axial-length constraints, lowering the DKI.

indeterminacystatic-kinematicdegree-of-freedom
7short3 marks

State Clapeyron's theorem of three moments (constant EIEI, no support settlement). Apply it to a continuous beam with two equal spans AB=BC=L=5mAB = BC = L = 5\,\text{m}, each carrying a UDL of w=16kN/mw = 16\,\text{kN/m}, with AA and CC simply supported. Find the moment over the interior support BB.

Theorem of three moments

For three consecutive supports 112233 over two spans of lengths L1L_1 and L2L_2 (constant EIEI, no settlement):

M1L1+2M2(L1+L2)+M3L2=6(A1xˉ1L1+A2xˉ2L2)M_1 L_1 + 2M_2(L_1+L_2) + M_3 L_2 = -6\left(\frac{A_1\bar{x}_1}{L_1}+\frac{A_2\bar{x}_2}{L_2}\right)

where the Axˉ/LA\bar x/L terms are the moment-area contributions of the free-bending-moment diagrams. For a span under UDL the standard right-hand term per span is wL34\dfrac{wL^3}{4}, so:

MAL1+2MB(L1+L2)+MCL2=w1L134w2L234M_A L_1 + 2M_B(L_1+L_2) + M_C L_2 = -\frac{w_1 L_1^3}{4} - \frac{w_2 L_2^3}{4}

Application

Ends simply supported: MA=0M_A = 0, MC=0M_C = 0. Equal spans L1=L2=L=5L_1=L_2=L=5, w=16w=16.

2MB(L+L)=wL34wL342M_B(L+L) = -\frac{wL^3}{4} - \frac{wL^3}{4} 4MBL=2wL34=wL324M_B L = -\frac{2wL^3}{4} = -\frac{wL^3}{2} MB=wL32×4L=wL28M_B = -\frac{wL^3}{2\times 4L} = -\frac{wL^2}{8} MB=16×528=16×258=4008=50kN\cdotpmM_B = -\frac{16\times 5^2}{8} = -\frac{16\times25}{8} = -\frac{400}{8} = -50\,\text{kN·m} MB=50kN\cdotpm (hogging)\boxed{M_B = 50\,\text{kN·m (hogging)}}

Check: matches the standard result MB=wL2/8M_B = wL^2/8 for two equal UDL spans.

three-moment-theoremcontinuous-beamsupport-moments
8short3 marks

Explain the basic assumptions of the portal method for approximate lateral-load analysis of building frames. A single-storey, two-bay portal frame has three columns (exterior, interior, exterior) and is subjected to a horizontal load of H=60kNH = 60\,\text{kN} at the beam level. Using the portal-method assumption for column-shear distribution, find the shear in each column.

Assumptions of the portal method

  1. A point of contraflexure (inflection) occurs at the mid-height of each column.
  2. A point of contraflexure occurs at the mid-span of each beam (girder).
  3. The horizontal shear carried by each interior column is twice that of each exterior column (each interior column is shared between two adjacent portal bays).

The method suits frames that are relatively low and wide, where lateral response is dominated by shear (portal) action.

Column shear distribution

Let the exterior-column shear =V=V. Then interior-column shear =2V=2V. For a two-bay frame: exterior + interior + exterior columns.

V+2V+V=H    4V=60    V=15kNV + 2V + V = H \;\Rightarrow\; 4V = 60 \;\Rightarrow\; V = 15\,\text{kN}
  • Exterior columns: V=15kNV = 15\,\text{kN} each
  • Interior column: 2V=30kN2V = 30\,\text{kN}
Vext=15kN (each),Vint=30kN\boxed{V_{ext}=15\,\text{kN (each)},\quad V_{int}=30\,\text{kN}}

Check: 15+30+15=60kN=H  15 + 30 + 15 = 60\,\text{kN} = H\;\checkmark

approximate-methodsportal-methodlateral-load
9short4 marks

Define the shape factor of a cross-section. Derive and compute the shape factor for (a) a rectangular section b×db \times d and (b) a solid circular section of diameter DD. Comment briefly on what a high shape factor indicates.

Definition

The shape factor SS is the ratio of the plastic moment MpM_p to the yield moment MyM_y, equivalently the ratio of the plastic section modulus ZpZ_p to the elastic section modulus ZeZ_e:

S=MpMy=ZpZeS=\frac{M_p}{M_y}=\frac{Z_p}{Z_e}

It measures the reserve strength of a section between first yield and full plastification.

(a) Rectangular section b×db\times d

Elastic modulus:

Ze=Iy=bd3/12d/2=bd26Z_e=\frac{I}{y}=\frac{bd^3/12}{d/2}=\frac{bd^2}{6}

Plastic modulus (two halves, each area bd/2bd/2, centroid lever arm d/4d/4):

Zp=2(bd2d4)=bd24Z_p=2\left(\frac{bd}{2}\cdot\frac{d}{4}\right)=\frac{bd^2}{4} S=ZpZe=bd2/4bd2/6=64=1.5S=\frac{Z_p}{Z_e}=\frac{bd^2/4}{bd^2/6}=\frac{6}{4}=1.5 Srect=1.5\boxed{S_{rect}=1.5}

(b) Solid circular section, diameter DD

Elastic modulus:

Ze=πD332Z_e=\frac{\pi D^3}{32}

Plastic modulus of a solid circle:

Zp=D36Z_p=\frac{D^3}{6} S=ZpZe=D3/6πD3/32=326π=3218.850=1.6981.70S=\frac{Z_p}{Z_e}=\frac{D^3/6}{\pi D^3/32}=\frac{32}{6\pi}=\frac{32}{18.850}=1.698\approx1.70 Scircle=1.70\boxed{S_{circle}=1.70}

Comment

A high shape factor (circle 1.70 > rectangle 1.50) means a larger fraction of the area lies near the neutral axis and is mobilised only after first yield, giving greater post-yield reserve. By contrast an I-section (shape factor ≈ 1.12–1.15) places material at the extreme fibres and is structurally more economical even though its shape factor is lower. A high shape factor signals large reserve, not necessarily efficient material use.

plastic-analysisshape-factorsection-modulus
10short3 marks

A fixed beam ABAB of span L=6mL = 6\,\text{m} and flexural rigidity EI=24000kN\cdotpm2EI = 24\,000\,\text{kN·m}^2 carries no transverse load, but support BB settles by Δ=12mm\Delta = 12\,\text{mm} relative to AA. Determine the end moments MAM_A and MBM_B induced by the settlement.

Concept

For a fixed–fixed beam, a relative support settlement Δ\Delta (chord rotation ψ=Δ/L\psi=\Delta/L) with both end rotations held at zero induces equal end moments of magnitude:

MA=MB=6EIΔL2M_A = M_B = \frac{6EI\,\Delta}{L^2}

This follows from the slope-deflection equations with θA=θB=0\theta_A=\theta_B=0:

MAB=2EIL(2θA+θB3ψ)=6EIψL=6EIΔL2M_{AB}=\frac{2EI}{L}\big(2\theta_A+\theta_B-3\psi\big)=-\frac{6EI\psi}{L}=-\frac{6EI\Delta}{L^2} MBA=2EIL(2θB+θA3ψ)=6EIΔL2M_{BA}=\frac{2EI}{L}\big(2\theta_B+\theta_A-3\psi\big)=-\frac{6EI\Delta}{L^2}

Computation

Given EI=24000kN\cdotpm2EI=24\,000\,\text{kN·m}^2, Δ=12mm=0.012m\Delta=12\,\text{mm}=0.012\,\text{m}, L=6mL=6\,\text{m}.

M=6×24000×0.01262=6×24000×0.01236M=\frac{6\times24\,000\times0.012}{6^2}=\frac{6\times24\,000\times0.012}{36}

Numerator: 6×24000=1440006\times24\,000=144\,000; 144000×0.012=1728144\,000\times0.012=1\,728.

M=172836=48kN\cdotpmM=\frac{1\,728}{36}=48\,\text{kN·m}

Result

MA=MB=48kN\cdotpm\boxed{M_A = M_B = 48\,\text{kN·m}}

Sense: With BB settling below AA, both end moments have magnitude 48kN\cdotpm48\,\text{kN·m}. The deflected shape is antisymmetric with a single point of contraflexure at mid-span, so the mid-span moment is zero (no transverse load).

force-methodfixed-beamsettlement
11short3 marks

Write the 4×44\times4 element stiffness matrix of a prismatic plane beam element (two nodes; each node has a transverse translation and a rotation; axial effects ignored) of length LL and flexural rigidity EIEI. Explain the physical meaning of one column of the matrix and state two key properties of element stiffness matrices.

Beam element stiffness matrix

Degrees of freedom ordered as {v1, θ1, v2, θ2}\{v_1,\ \theta_1,\ v_2,\ \theta_2\} (transverse displacement and rotation at node 1, then node 2):

[k]=EIL3[126L126L6L4L26L2L2126L126L6L2L26L4L2][k]=\frac{EI}{L^3}\begin{bmatrix} 12 & 6L & -12 & 6L \\ 6L & 4L^2 & -6L & 2L^2 \\ -12 & -6L & 12 & -6L \\ 6L & 2L^2 & -6L & 4L^2 \end{bmatrix}

Physical meaning of a column

Each column gives the nodal forces/moments required to produce a unit value of the corresponding DOF while all other DOFs are held at zero.

Example — column 2 (corresponding to θ1=1\theta_1 = 1, all other DOFs zero) gives the end actions:

  • Force at node 1: 6EIL2\dfrac{6EI}{L^2}
  • Moment at node 1: 4EIL\dfrac{4EI}{L}
  • Force at node 2: 6EIL2-\dfrac{6EI}{L^2}
  • Moment at node 2: 2EIL\dfrac{2EI}{L}

These match the slope-deflection actions for a unit near-end rotation: near-end stiffness 4EI/L4EI/L and carry-over moment 2EI/L2EI/L at the far end.

Two key properties

  1. Symmetry: [k]=[k]T[k]=[k]^T (a consequence of the Maxwell–Betti reciprocal theorem; kij=kjik_{ij}=k_{ji}).
  2. Singularity / positive semi-definite: the unconstrained element matrix is singular (det[k]=0\det[k]=0) because it admits rigid-body modes (rigid translation and rigid rotation produce no internal forces); it becomes positive-definite only after sufficient supports are applied.
matrix-stiffness-methodelement-stiffnessbeam-element

Frequently asked questions

Where can I find the BE Civil Engineering (IOE, TU) Theory of Structures II (IOE, CE 602) question paper 2076?
The full BE Civil Engineering (IOE, TU) Theory of Structures II (IOE, CE 602) 2076 (regular) question paper is available free on Kekkei. You can read every question online and attempt the paper under timed exam conditions.
Does the Theory of Structures II (IOE, CE 602) 2076 paper come with solutions?
Yes. Every question on this Theory of Structures II (IOE, CE 602) past paper includes a step-by-step solution, plus instant AI feedback when you attempt it on Kekkei.
How many marks is the BE Civil Engineering (IOE, TU) Theory of Structures II (IOE, CE 602) 2076 paper?
The BE Civil Engineering (IOE, TU) Theory of Structures II (IOE, CE 602) 2076 paper carries 80 full marks and is meant to be completed in 180 minutes, across 11 questions.
Is practising this Theory of Structures II (IOE, CE 602) past paper free?
Yes — reading and attempting this Theory of Structures II (IOE, CE 602) past paper on Kekkei is completely free.